Short answer:
there is no real advantage to using marine batteries unless they are the only ones available or you're getting a major discount on them compared to the automotive version.
Long answer:
Deep cycle marine batteries have different charge and discharge rates than an equivalent 24F (Flooded lead acid) or 24MF (Maintenance Free) type battery.
Also they rate the cranking amps differently. MCA is measured at 32°F whereas CCA is at 0 °F
Also the deep cycle part in the name is because it is designed to discharge further and last longer while doing so, but in exchange it gives up cranking amps and overall life expectancy for cranking.
The only real advantage to using a marine battery vs a standard automotive battery is if you use the battery power a lot when the engine isn't running.
This answer over on Quora gives a lot more detail
Yes — you can use a deep‑cycle marine battery in a car, but there are trade-offs and some installation/charging considerations. Below are the key points to evaluate before making the swap.
Performance and suitability
- Cranking vs. cycling design: Automotive (starting) batteries are optimized for very high cold‑cranking amps (CCA) for short bursts to start the engine. Deep‑cycle marine batteries are designed to deliver lower current for long periods and tolerate repeated deep discharge. A deep‑cycle will start most cars fine but typically provides lower CCA than a similarly sized starting battery.
- Reserve capacity: Deep‑cycle batteries often have higher reserve capacity (useful for accessories when engine is off) but slower cold starts.
- Life under starting duty: Repeated use as a starter battery (frequent cold starts, short recharge cycles) can shorten a deep‑cycle’s life compared with a purpose-built starting battery.
Charging and electrical system
- Charging profile: Car alternators and on‑board chargers are tuned for lead‑acid starting batteries. Most deep‑cycle lead‑acid types (flooded, AGM, gel) accept the same nominal charging voltages, but:
- Gel batteries are sensitive to overvoltage; they require lower float/absorption voltages.
- AGM deep‑cycle tolerates higher charge rates and is often the easiest deep‑cycle to use in cars.
- Alternator capacity: If the battery has a much larger capacity than stock, the alternator will take longer to restore charge after starting or accessory use. That’s not harmful per se but can lead to more engine run time needed to recharge.
- Charge algorithm mismatch: Repeated partial charges from short drives can reduce battery life. Smart charging (DC‑DC charger or multi‑stage regulator) mitigates this.
Physical and safety considerations
- Size and fit: Marine deep‑cycle cases (group sizes) may differ. Confirm physical dimensions and terminal locations; ensure secure mounting and proper venting for flooded cells.
- Venting and hydrogen: Flooded deep‑cycle batteries vent hydrogen during charge; they must be installed in a ventilated area and terminals protected. AGM and gel are lower venting risk but still require care.
- Weight: Deep‑cycle batteries are often heavier, which can affect handling if replacing multiple units or using a much larger battery.
Practical outcomes by typical scenarios
- Occasional use in daily driver: Acceptable if the battery’s CCA rating is sufficient for your engine and you understand potentially reduced cranking in very cold weather.
- Heavy accessory load / audio systems: A deep‑cycle (or dual‑purpose starting/deep‑cycle) can be a better choice than a pure starter battery because it handles deep discharge for accessories.
- Long idling, marine trailer vehicles, or vehicles used off‑grid: Deep‑cycle is advantageous for powering loads when engine is off, especially when paired with appropriate charging systems.
Recommendations
- Pick the right chemistry: AGM deep‑cycle gives the best compatibility with car charging systems; avoid gel unless your charger/alternator is compatible.
- Match CCA for cold climates: Ensure the chosen deep‑cycle provides sufficient CCA for reliable starting in expected temperatures.
- Use a dual‑purpose battery if unsure: Starting/deep‑cycle (marine dual) batteries are engineered to provide higher CCA and more cycling tolerance — a good compromise.
- Upgrade charging if needed: Install a multi‑stage alternator regulator, DC‑DC charger, or a smart external charger if you frequently run accessories or have long charge recovery needs.
- Secure and ventilate properly: Fit battery in an approved tray, secure terminals, and vent flooded cells to avoid hydrogen buildup.
Bottom line: A deep‑cycle marine battery will work in a car for many uses, and can be preferable for accessory-heavy applications, but expect lower cranking performance, possible shortened life under pure starting duty, and pay attention to chemistry, charging profile, physical fit, and ventilation.